Nickel's Pit BBQ » Shop

Nickel's Pit BBQ

Order Our Products Online!

Our premium original recipe sauces are produced and bottled right here in Upstate NY, packaged in beautiful glass bottles, and shipped directly to you.

Each sauce has a unique character, and all of our sauces can be used as a condiment or to finish your favorite grilled items. These sauces will enhance the flavor of just about anything - pork, beef, chicken, turkey, vegetables, fries and tots, pizza or anything else you can imagine.

Gift Certificates

Click Here » Gift Certificates Available!

Nickel's Pit BBQ - House BBQ Sauce

House BBQ

Nickel’s original tomato-based sauce. Sweet but tangy, BBQ like us — Upstate Style!

Net Weight 19.5 oz
Price: $4.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Hot BBQ Sauce


Want to kick it up a notch? Our house BBQ with a spicy, smoky bite. Put it on everything.

Net Weight 19.5 oz
Price: $4.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Carolina BBQ Sauce

Carolina BBQ

Mustard, vinegar, brown sugar based sauce. A bit of the South right here in Watkins Glen!

Net Weight 18 oz.
Price: $4.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Chicken Sauce

Chicken Sauce

Nickel’s Legendary Chicken Sauce. Enjoy!

Net Weight 16.00 oz
Price: $4.49

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Original Hot Sauce

Original Hot Sauce

Gluten Free • No MSG • No High Fructose Corn Syrup!

Net Weight 6.5 fl. oz
Price: $5.99

Add to Cart
Nickel's Pit BBQ - Everything BBQ Rub

Everything BBQ Rub

Everything BBQ Rub is great on beef, chicken, pork and fish too!

Net Weight 5 oz.
Price: $5.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Beef and Burger Rub

Beef & Burger Rub

Great on steaks, brisket and an excellent way to make an exceptional burger!

Net Weight 4.5 oz.
Price: $5.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ T-Shirts

Nickel’s T-Shirt

Be a proud member of the Nickel’s family. Our classic black tee with distressed white logo. Represent Nickel’s - Represent Watkins Glen!

Price: $15.99

Nickel's Pit BBQ

Nickel's Pit BBQ
» Gift Cards

The Perfect Gift for the Holidays!

Choose any amount and receive your gift card in the mail - no tax and no shipping!

Nickel's Pit BBQ Gift Card:

Choose Gift Card Amount

Nickel's Pit BBQ

Nickel's Pit BBQ is an authentic American BBQ restaurant with an upstate NY edge. Our home is the historic Watkins Glen fire department building, located on N. Franklin St. – the main drag in one of the coolest small towns in America. » Read More

Thursday: 5 - 9
Friday: 5 - 9
Saturday: 5 - 9
Sunday: 10 - 2

Guests can view our Facebook for a list of special events and theme nights.


Contact Nickels Pit BBQ

Taste Of NY
Nickel's Pit Facebook   Nickel's Pit Twitter   Nickel's Pit Flickr   Rooster Fish Brewing
©2018 • All Rights Reserved • Website Design By